A year ago when the university selected a new President, a lot of people–including a number of faculty and staff–voiced concern about Mike Garrison.

They worried about cronyism and his links to state politicians and his links to the Board of Governors who selected him.

Unfortunately, a year after his selection, he has placed WVU in the national news for cronyism and links to state politicians as an independent panel decided that Heather Bresch was erroneously given her MBA.

Why is this a big deal? Because Heather Bresch is the daughter of WV Governor Joe Manchin. Because when reports first surfaced that she had not in fact earned her degree, her first call was directly to Mike Garrison. Because when a committee was rushed together to look into whether she had earned her degree or not (they were given a single weekend to collect evidence) several Garrison staffers were on the committee. Because despite almost no evidence that she had in fact completed her course work, the committee ruled that she should be granted the credits retroactively and given her degree.

I held my tongue on Garrison’s selection last year, despite my concerns, hoping that he would show that his detractors were wrong. But now, a year after his selection, it seems that my concerns may well have been justified.

Mike Garrison, when you are in the public eye, when you represent WVU, you must act in a way that is above suspicion when it comes to the University. If there is any doubt as to the ethics or morality of an action, you must err on the side of caution, keeping the reputation on the University in mind. You failed to do that in this situation, and have instead tarnished the reputation of WVU.

This is not a good way to celebrate the anniversary of your selection.