Go read what Jeanne at Body and Soul has posted about the abuses at Abu Garab. She’s been quiet for awhile, and has a lot to say.
I haven’t been writing about it, because I don’t know what to say, but Jean touches on many of the problems in how we in the US are dealing with it. I was reading an editorial in US News that I thought was off the mark, but I think that Jean addresses many of those issues, at least obliqely: it doesn’t matter that torture and abuse are the norm for most governments in the Middle East, we are the United States and we are not supposed to stoop to such levels. Those actions, taken in our name, reflect all of us.
As far as the blame game, Jean asks “Why do we want to absolve people implementing immoral policies?” I believe that the answer is related to why the far right sees war protesters as unpatriotic and condemns those who disagree with the war with a broad brush: Many remember, all to well, the way that soldiers were treated during Vietnam. Soldiers who had been drafted, who had been sent overseas to fight in a war not of their choosing, were ostracized by society. This was a terrible thing for us to have done, and in our efforts not to repeat the past many are going in the other direction: claiming that anything being against the war puts our soldiers at risk.
And to be honest I’m of two minds about this. Soldiers did not create the policy that placed them in Iraq. People join the military for many reasons, but regardless of the reasons, they don’t make policy. They are not responsible for where they are, they are only responsible for the actions they take while they are there.
Where does responsibility lie? With the individual soldiers? Certainly. They are responsible for their own actions. But the responsibility does not end there. They did not place themselves in that situation (regardless of whether or not they were ordered to take the actions they took). The US has placed soldiers where they are. The US military is responsible for the selection and training of those soldiers. The chain of command goes all the way up to Rumsfeld and Bush. They are responsible for soldiers where they are now.
But ultimately, that responsiblity lies with the American people. We elect the president and congress to represent us, and actions that are taken by those who represent us, reflect upon us.
The action of those soldiers reflects upon us. They are Americans. They represent America. They are America, and we have to acknowledge this. We cannot simply shunt it aside with glib statements of “that’s not the America I know.” Their actions are our actions.
Because of this, it is wrong to treat the military with the disrespect such as happened during Vietnam, because they are doing little more than taking actions that ceom from us.
Ultimately, the blood is on our hands.